New York magazine is reporting that actor John C. Reilly is in serious talks to play the role of Haymitch Abernathy in the big screen adaptation of The Hunger Games. According to the magazine, the role has been offered to him but his casting is not yet official. I, for one, think this is another case of brilliant casting! While I didn’t immediately think of John C. Reilly as Haymitch while reading the books, I can absolutely see how he could play the role perfectly. Read on for all the rumored deets about this reported casting.

Loaded question: Who plays a paunchy, pathetic drunk better than John C. Reilly? Actually, that’s a bit of a trick, because the answer, of course, is no one. And for that reason, we’re told it will be the Oscar-nominated Reilly who’ll be soon be getting the offer to play Haymitch Abernathy in the forthcoming adaptation of Suzanne Collins’s The Hunger Games at Lionsgate Films. If you’ve read Collins’s bestselling book, you already know that Abernathy is the only living person from Panem’s District 12 to ever win The Hunger Games, and now serves as a mentor, albeit an alcoholic one, to district tributes Katniss Everdeen (Jennifer Lawrence) and Peeta Mellark (Josh Hutcherson) … We’re also told that Reilly had been in talks to join Disney’s Oz, the Great and the Powerful as the sidekick to James Franco’s Wizard character, but that those talks had stalled; now we know why.
Altho this news is not yet official, I would be THRILLED if Reilly ends up with the role. He deffo has the look and absolutely has the acting chops to play the part. I am very pleased with the way the cast of The Hunger Games is turning out. Even tho I don’t agree with ALL of the casting thus far **cough** Hunter Parrish should be Peeta Mellark **cough** I am generally very happy with the way things are turning out and am SO excited about seeing The Hunger Games come to life on the big screen. What do y’all think of John C. Reilly as Haymitch? Is he the choice for you? If not, who would play the role better?
Any guesses which character casting we’ll be hearing about next?
[Source]





























I like john c. reilly, I can see him as haymitch. I pictured jeff bridges while I was reading (listening, actually, to the audiobooks) but I think that’s because I watched true grit just before I started hunger games. can’t wait to see who they pick for cinna! I think hugh dancy would be a good choice.
Personally i still think Robert Downey jr is perfect for haymitch, but John c Reilly would be good too I think. As for cinna, Hugh dancy. No question. He’s just soooooo perfect.
I’m pretty happy about the casting so far(with the exception of Josh Hutcherson for peeta- it REALLY needed to be hunter Parrish in my eyes), so I’m sure the casting people will make the right decision. They know best.
Holy Cheese agreed from the beginning i’ve pictured haymitch as Robert Downey Jr and Cinna as Hugh Dancy well beginning being as soon as i heard they were making the movie lol and their choice for peeta is the worst by far they BETTER dye his hair no joke i can live with the rest of the choices theyve made so long as they get these two right :)
This is PERFECT!!!!! Every time you post new info I just get that much more excited – thank you!!
I fully support John C Reilly as Haymitch!
NO. I don’t think I like this. NONONONONONO.
Hunter Parrish for Finnick Odair!!
Omg! Vicky i pictured him asian too! They never described him that way but i pictured him asian nonetheless!
Yeah, he really is a great actor and can pull off just about anything. He was amazing in Chicago.
Perfect.
I think this role is Perfect for John C. Reilly. I could see him pulling off the drunken Haymitch very well!!
Adam Lambert for Cenna.
My thoughts exactly!!
This is okay for Haymitch, I can see it. ALL of the other actors I’ve heard so far REALLY make me less and less interested in seeing the movie. I don’t know if I’m the only one, but I totally pictured Project Runway’s Christian Siriano as Cinna.
Always pictured Hugh Laurie as Haymitch! haha
Same here! :D
He will NEVER ever be Haymitch! That is the stupidest ide ive EVER heard!
Haymitch is one of my 4 favourite characters and they cannot ruin him but casting John. I actually love him as an actor but not as Haymiych…Hugh Laurie on the other hand…:)
please, please NO!!! :(
I always pictured Robert Downey JR (or someone similar) reading the books. NO!
Robert Downey Jr is the PERFECT Haymitch! This guy on here should NeveR be Haymitch!!
Russell Crowe is my perfect Haymitch.
I think Hugh Laurie would be PERFECT as Haymitch!