And so … another season of Survivor has come to an end and another ultimate Survivor has been chosen. In case you have yet to watch last night’s ep and you wish to remain unspoiled, you might want to stay away from the Internets until you do so. For the rest of us, let’s get down to discussin’ who was voted the winner of Survivor: Nicaragua lat night …
Going into the finale episode that aired last night, the final 5 contestants left were Dan Lembo, Holly Hoffman, Sash aka Matthew Lenahan, Chase Rice and Fabio aka Judson Birza … then Dan got voted off … then Holly … and then there were 3:

The only reason Fabio managed to make it to the final 3 was because he managed to win the last three immunity challenges of the game … fortunately for him, the games focused on puzzles and the final endurance challenge was not a physical one. The final 3 players — Chace, Fabio and Sash — plead their cases to the jury and a winner was selected … by a very close vote.
In the end … Fabio managed to win the whole shebang … and $1 million dollars:

Time and again during “Survivor: Nicaragua,” fans of the show complained loudly that this latest batch of contestants was by far the dumbest group to ever play the game. And during the finale, the proof of that was in the win. Pretty boy Jud Birza, better known to fans as Fabio, beat Chase Rice by one vote to take the title of Sole Survivor and the million-dollar prize. He also became the youngest player at age 21 to win the game. It was interesting that it came down to these two guys — Sash Lenahan didn’t get any love from the jury — because it almost seemed like a contest between dumb and dumber. (Jury member Marty Piombo even suggested a Dumber Than a Bag of Hammers Award, most likely for Chase, whom he couldn’t stand.) The show and the contestants regularly reminded viewers how stupid Chase was in his strategy. He repeatedly befriended and earned the trust of other contestants, only to backstab and vote them out each and every time. All that flip-flopping, backstabbing and playing based on his emotions rather than his head should have made it next to impossible for him to earn any votes, yet he received four. Did he play the game that much better than strategist Sash? Maybe, maybe not. Perhaps the fact that he received four votes to Sash’s zero had something to do with the final Tribal Council. When asked what he would do if he won the million dollars, Chase replied that $100,000 would be going to charity, and that he’d be taking care of his mom. It’s hard not to want to reward good intentions. As for Fabio, he kicked off the season playing the role of “the dumb blond,” as Shannon Elkins, who was voted off the second week, said. It was hard to argue that, as week after week, the student and model did things that many would qualify as dumb, from peeing in a pool everyone had to swim in to running around barefoot in a rain forest and getting stabbed in the foot by a branch. Were it not for his three consecutive immunity-challenge wins at the end of the game, he would’ve never had a shot. Lucky for him, he did win, and it didn’t hurt that — as he reminded the jury — he played a friendly game and never had to hurt anyone’s feelings to get where he was.
Not only did Fabio do himself a lot of favors by winning the final immunity challenges but his answers during the jury questioning really helped his case … he only beat Chase by 1 vote to win the million bucks. I didn’t LOVE this season of Survivor but it was entertaining. In the end, I really didn’t care who won, to be honest. I’m glad that Fabio was able to sneak in there and win the whole thing but I would’ve been just as happy if Chase had managed to win instead.
What I was really surprised by was the fact that Fabio was VERY OBVIOUSLY on something during the live reunion special. His glassy eyes were a tip-off that he was high on … something. Then, when he tried to give answers to questions … I was sure the guy was either baked or trippin’. It was clear that Survivor producers also believed him to be out of it because after Jeff Probst asked him a few questions in the beginning (and after he gave nonsense answers), they NEVER let Fabio speak again for the rest of the reunion special. Never in Survivor history have they ignored and NOT let the winner talk on the reunion special. Now that he’s got a million bucks, I can only imagine what Fabio plans to spend all that GREEN on.
Oh and Jane Hammett-Bright won the fan favorite award of $100,000 … which was well-deserved, I think. But, yeah, as I said … this season of Survivor was fun to watch but … it wasn’t really all that exciting. Did you watch? Are you happy with this season’s winner?
[Photo credit: Wireimage; Source]





























I was happy Fabio won last night. I think he may have acted clueless toward people during the game but I believe he knew a lot more than he let on. I also think it was a PERFECT move to basically call out both Sash and Chase during the final four Tribal Council and then take the two of them after the jury heard enough to be annoyed at the both of them. I really think that was a great move and he really deserved the million!
I do agree however, that this wasn’t my favorite season of survivor. I’m excited for the twist next season though. It will be interesting to see how that changes the game!
@Laura — “I think he may have acted clueless toward people during the game but I believe he knew a lot more than he let on.” I totally disagree. I do NOT believe he was strategic at all nor do I believe that he knew what the hell was going on for most of the season. I also think he got a bit lucky and his prowess at puzzles pushed him into the position that gave him the win. Not for one second do I believe that Fabio was cunning or calculating.
I don’t necessarily think he was cunning….but I think he had a bit of calculation. As much as Sash? No…but there is a social game to be played that people like Sash don’t give enough credit to.
I agree that this season of Survivor seems dumber than ever. It annoyed me more than anything that NaOnka was allowed to walk away with a clue to the idol and none of her tribe asked her about it (the pushing and shoving…whatever…but why didn’t the rest of them want the clue!?!?!)
I do not think that Fabio was the all around most strategic player in the game…but I do think he knew what he was doing in the tribal outing Sash and Chase to the Jury and then getting rid of Holly. I would have been the LEAST happy with Chase winning since he was just going nuts the whole game and backstabbing with a new “plan” or no plan every day…at least Sash played a game…but they were all too mad for him to win. (Which I would argue makes some of the Jury a good amount dumber than what they thought of Fabio)
Can we talk about Shannon “calling a duck a duck” for a second?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-sR7VryViuk
Cringeworthy. But I like how Jeff handled things, leaving Shannon to look like the idiot that he is.
This season had the dumbest cast ever. It was entertaining, but they were all complete morons. I agree with Laura, Chase had no idea what he was doing the entire season. Sooo glad he didn’t win!
“Fabio” is from a small town next to my hometown. Did you know he was the face of Abecrombie & Fitch for awhile back when he was 17/18? One of his pictures was pretty famous too. I tried to put the link to the pictures…but I guess I can’t do that. Anyway…it’s all on his Facebook page which is basically open to the public to look at. I kind of find it hard to believe that he was roughing it at all after that ad campaign…but besides all the partying (which is pretty normal for a kid his age) he seems like a good guy, so although I’m a little afraid what he’ll do with that money, he deserves it.
I am SUPER happy that Fabio won because that meant I won the Survivor pool at work. :-)
I enjoyed watching this season…not the best but entertaining.
I was happy to see Jud win. I will call him by his given name because he’s a local boy – just a few miles away. Whether or not he was,”a bit out of it”,” at the finale – I really don’t think he was prepared to win. Although he said he was, he seemed like a deer in the headlights. And without a cohesive thought. I’ll call it jubliation. We don’t breed them really smart around here. But he did okay!
I’m from lake st louis, jud’s home town, and went to school with him since kindergarten.. Even though he seemed kind of dumb on te show, he is actually really smart.. He was always in the gifted classes and such.