Aug 26, 2009
Chris Brown Formally Sentenced For His Assault Conviction
Plus new info on ChRihanna's violent relationship

Yesterday Chris Brown was in LA Court to face formal sentencing for his June criminal conviction for assaulting his former girlfriend Rihanna last February. As you may recall, Brown was due to be sentenced earlier this month but was delayed a couple of weeks. Brown was sentenced to 5 years probation, 6 months (or 1,400 hours) of community service and is ordered by the judge to NOT to be in contact with Rihanna for the duration of his 5 year probation (he also must stay at least 10 yards from her if they attend the same event). Here are pics of Brown and his lawyer Mark Geragos in court at yesterday’s sentencing:


Chris Brown will spend 1,400 hours removing graffiti and washing cars for assaulting Rihanna. Brown, 20, was formally sentenced in a Los Angeles courtroom Tuesday to six months of community labor in Virginia after he pleaded guilty in June to one count of felony assault against Rihanna, 21. Brown’s six-month labor sentence will be supervised by the chief of police in Richmond, Va., who wrote to the judge that Brown would perform graffiti removal, cleaning and maintaining grounds, and washing cars. “Brown’s labor hours will be flexible to accommodate his entertainment career,” according to DA spokeswoman Sandi Gibbons. The singer, who looked solemn and wore a black pinstripe suit and matching tie, was also sentenced to five years of probation, a year of domestic violence classes, and was ordered to pay fines. He was accompanied in the courtroom by his mother and at least one bodyguard. As part of his plea bargain with prosecutors, a second felony charge of making criminal threats was dropped. Rihanna was not present for the hearing. Donald Etra, an attorney for the “Umbrella” singer, had previously asked the judge for lesser restrictions on communication and contact between the two singers. However, L.A. Superior Court Judge Patricia Schnegg ordered Brown not to have any communication with Rihanna for the next five years, which includes phone and email contact. Brown was also ordered not to come within 100 yards of Rihanna – 10 yards if they’re both at the same event. Toward the end of the hearing, Judge Schnegg warned Brown, in an apparent reference to reports that the two singers may have had contact against court order: “I’m not immune to any chatter on the airwaves. Do you understand, Mr. Brown, that any violation of this order is a violation of your probation and it comes with the possible penalty of prison?” Brown responded “Yes.” Asked if Rihanna was disappointed by the stay-away order, her lawyer stated: “There were no surprises today. The decision was up to the court, not Rihanna.” Etra added that Rihanna does have the option of asking the court to soften the stay-away order down the line, but he wouldn’t say if she plans to do so. Etra added that while the order specifically forbids Brown from contacting Rihanna, she was also warned by the court back in June not to contact him.

I have to say, the order that Chris has to stay away from Rihanna for such a long time is surprising, I don’t recall hearing that that was part of any deal previously reported. Also, in the wake of Brown‘s sentencing, new documents have come to light chronicling a history of violence between the couple BEFORE he physically assaulted her in February of this year. After the jump, check out the deets of their violent relationship if you dare …

Rihanna and Chris Brown had two previous violent episodes before the Feb. 8 fight, which ultimately led to Brown’s arrest and felony conviction, court documents reveal. The “Umbrella” singer allegedly slapped Brown in a heated argument three months prior to the February incident, according to Brown’s probation review released Tuesday. In that previous fight, which occurred in Europe, Brown responded by pushing Rihanna into a wall, the documents say. The couple “were involved in a verbal dispute and [she] slapped [him].” Brown “responded by shoving her into a wall.” A second fight occurred about three weeks prior to the Feb. 8 incident. Brown and Rihanna “were visiting Barbados and were driving a Range Rover loaned to them,” according to the documents. “They had an argument inside the car. [Brown] exited and broke the front driver and passenger side windows of the car. No one was injured during the incident.” The documents also reveal that in the Feb. 8 incident, which began after Brown allegedly received a text message from a previous lover, that Rihanna “said she became ‘enraged’ and slammed both of her fists against the dashboard,” which led to Brown pulling the Lamborghini over and trying to force her out, which escalated into a physical fight. Lawyers for both Rihanna, 21, and Brown, 20, weren’t immediately available for comment. In a June 26 interview with his probation officer, Brown stated that since the Feb. 8 fight, he had been very “depressed.” Brown stated he grew up watching his mother being physically abused and said he did not want to “carry on that cycle.” Brown repeatedly told the officer he regretted the incident, and said he initially wanted to plead guilty right away, but his attorney advised against it. “I want to take responsibility for my mistake,” Brown told the officer, adding he is “totally remorseful for what I have done.”

There had been rumors of violent fights between these two in the days before this last assault so none of this is really surprising. Neither is it surprising that Chris grew up in a violent home, which very likely had an impact on how he turned out. Violence begets violence. It’s not an excuse, just an explanation. Hopefully Chris Brown will finally learn the error of this kind of behavior and will be able to live his life from here on out as a non-violent man. He’s young, there’s still hope.

[Photo credit: Splash News; Source, Source]

Like PITNB on Facebook

47 Comments. Add Yours

1 2 3
  1. Pixie says:

    saying a women doesn’t have the right to go around slapping anyone she’s having an argument with, doesn’t mean i’m defending chris brown. is he disgusting and a horrible human being for beating her, YES he is. i never said rihanna deserved to get choked and beaten. all i said was just as he had no right to lay a hand on her, she has no right to lay a hand on him.

  2. Suzanne says:

    But by even saying that you are justifying his actions. Don’t you see that? I agree, she shouldn’t have been physical with him either. Violence in any form = complete badness. But this is two completely separate incidents. And when he beat the crap out of her in February the only “provocation” was her hitting his f*cking car.

    I am not trying to be negative toward anyone posting comments, cause you are entitled to you opinions. I just can’t comprehend how anyone could say that she in any way remotely deserved what he did to her. And by bringing up a past incident where she slapped him (and then he shoved her into a wall), that is how it comes across to me.

  3. Vida says:

    Is anyone going to question Rihannas actions??
    She slapped him…violence is voilence, whether its from a man OR a woman!
    On the last incident, she began beating her fists against his car….that shows she has some violent issues she needs to work on also!!!!

  4. Spice says:

    I think that it is a true statement that Rhianna shouldn’t act out in violence but I don’t think that automatically makes her open to whatever concequences just because she initated it in the past.

    Here’s the deal, Rhinna would not be able to do the harm to Chris that he can do to her. She can’t overpower him so the bigger person needs to show more restraint because of the damage he can do verses what she can do. It doesn’t give her the right to act out either but he could walk away and cut ties with her also. A normal person probably would and say I’m not going to put myself in that postition because when he lets loose ,its waaaaay more damaging then when she does. He needed to not let himself get in that position and he did.

    She probably needs help too. It doesn’t surprise me that she wants to be with him regarless. I be she even regets that it’s gone this far and wishes no one would have ever found out. It’s a sad thing. People will put up with a lot for what the precieve as love.

  5. CHASE says:

    I don’t believe any of it! This is what really happened: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MIhshI34RSc – LOL!

  6. liza says:

    wow…just by saying i think she needed to take some responsibility for her actions…someone mistaking thought i said she deserved to be hit. NO! NOT AT ALL! all that means is she needs to stand up and take some (not all…just some) responsibility for allowing a violent relationship continue. meaning she also needs some type of counseling. it is never ok for anyone to hit someone…no matter what the situation. And because i believe both parties a somewhat responsible dosen’t mean i think its ok for men to hit women or women to hit men.

  7. Pixie says:

    @ suzanne: i agree they are two separate incidents. i didn’t mean to imply that he had the right to beat (during the feb car incident) her cause she has slapped him in an earlier incident. i think she needs to also look at herself and question why she feels the urge to slap anyone during an argument and to question why she stayed in an abusive relationship. only by taking responsibility and saying ok something is wrong with me that i allow a guy to beat me can she break the cycle of abuse.

  8. Michelle says:

    It seems to me that there is more to this story than what originally met the eye. I feel that even though Chris Brown did in fact hit her and cause her bodily damage, Rihanna has been playing the part of the innocent victim when she in fact, has also hit him. Why is it that it’s not okay for a man to hit a woman but a woman can hit a man without any reprocussions? Obviously there was a lot more going on with the couple than anyone thought. While it’s still a horrible thing what transpired the night in the car, obviously Chris Brown has also been a victim of abuse from Rihanna and I feel like he isn’t getting any support for that.She isn’t getting any heat for it either. I’m really over her, she walks around like she’s queen of the Earth and really she’s got her own issues.

  9. Krissy says:

    Suzanne said: ” I just can’t comprehend how anyone could say that she in any way remotely deserved what he did to her. And by bringing up a past incident where she slapped him (and then he shoved her into a wall), that is how it comes across to me.”

    I completely agree.

  10. Krissy says:

    Liza, how do you know Rhianna isn’t in some type of counseling? Pixie, how do you know she isn’t in therapy addressing those very issues? Just because she doesn’t make her recovery a public spectacle doesn’t mean that she isn’t getting help or taking responsibility.

  11. jamie-o says:

    lord help both of ‘em. if the situation were reversed and she had choked and bit and beaten *him* to a bloody pulp, i hope we’d throw the book at rihanna too.

    knowing *she hit him in the past* does indeed greatly decrease my respect for her. but i don’t blame her for his actions. or him, for her actions!

    not interested in either of these losers anymore.

  12. bikerbabe says:

    Don’t judge Rhianna for her actions during this situation. Unless you have ever been in an abusive relationship you have no idea what she has been through and NONE of what happened is her fault. Not many guys start out pushing and shoving a woman around, it happens gradually and by the time you’ve gotten to that place it’s likely she didn’t realize how bad it really was. Have some compassion.

  13. Suzanne says:

    100% bikerbabe. Michelle: She has not made one single comment on anything. How the hell is she “playing the victim”. She is the f*cking victim. He pled guilty and “faux-pologised” on the interweb.

    Chris Brown doesn’t deserve any f*cking support. He is a guy using his past to excuse what he did. I am sick of people making excuses for him.

    Abusive relationships are something that I hope none of you ever have to go through. Abusers make you feel like nothing, and that all you can get and deserve is them. That you are not worthy of anything better and that you deserve everything they heap on you.

    People in these relationships – famous or not – man or woman – should never be expected to “take responsibility” for remaining in that relationship and somehow “take responsibility” for what happens to them. That is exactly the same as saying that someone who walks home alone after dark should “take responsibility” for being assaulted in an alley.

    Compassion is right. Try being a f*cking human being.

  14. kammy says:

    Sounds like they both need lessons on not putting your hands against another person, male or female. @Suzanne- they are both victims as they both have histories of being violent in their relationships.

  15. Pixie says:

    if i walk in a dark alley knowing there is someone there who will beat me, then yes i am in part responsible if i get beaten. that doesn’t excuse the person that beat me, but i didn’t have to choose to walk in that dark alley knowing the person was there. i could have left that alley and gone another way. are we saying rihanna had no choice but to stay in that abusive relationship? she had choices, she had the resources to get out but for whatever reason she chose to stay. does that excuse chris brown from his actions? absolutely not, he as well chose to beat her.

  16. Pixie says:

    @krissy, you are correct in stating we don’t know whether she is or isn’t in therapy addressing these issues but i’m just saying i hope she is. if she doesn’t she is just gonna find herself in another abusive relationship.

  17. Nicola says:

    A man is stronger than a woman. Yes, he was more violent, but she was also violent toward him. Rhianna isn’t completely faultless just because she didn’t damage him as much as he damaged her. Sounds like there was provocation from Rhianna each time. A slap, a violent outburst (albeit not toward him, but the car). What it doesn’t say of course is who started the verbal arguements. But whatever, he’s getting what he deserves for his attack. However I think Rhianna is at fault for some part too. You cannot always condemn the man just because he is a man, just because they are stronger, and when there is evidence to support the fact that the woman did provoke the actions. Doesn’t absolve him, but it’s a two way street.
    You can get riled up about it pointlessly but if their roles were reversed so that she beat him up and he provoked her, you’d be foaming at the mouth for him provoking her. I bet. Women may be weaker but we’re never infallible when it comes to these situations. We can take partial blame too :/

  18. not saying my name says:

    so i read the report and what chris brown did was horrible! he sould have got jail time. for people saying he was provoked, what a joke! i have seen pics of rianna and chris brown side by side and he looks a hell of a lot bigger then her. i doubt she did any damage. i know im gonna get people saying it doesnt matter but it does…im not proud of my moment but i once slapped my boyfriend (i have never done so again and this was 3 years ago) and he just walked away, believe me he was pissed as hell fists clenched. theres not one day that goes by that i dont regret it. but he walked away when he didnt have to. he could have easily done to me what chris brown did to rihanna. so chris brown could have walked awy but he didnt.

  19. lilly says:

    slapping someone is not the same as beating someone. I was in a relationship with a guy who cheated on me and verbally abused me, i caught him cheating on me, i slapped him, and he almost killed me, he grabbed and put me on the ground and punched me, and kicked me in the face. I didnt deserve that, and what he did to was physical abuse. Yea maybe rihanna did slap him but no matter what, a guy should never hit a woman, and if he was a real man he would not try to hit her, he could of easily stopped the car and get out and leave her there and let her calm down, theres no excuse for what he did. So you ppl are crazy if u think that girl deserved to beatin on. You could be the biggest bitch in the world and still dont deserve that. You would slap ur man to if he was getting text msgs or calls from an ex gf or whatever. Chris is just an idiot, and i dont think he will change, if he was that upset about what he done, and if he was depressed then he should of said an apology or given a statement as soon as this happened. Instead he ran away like an ass that he is, then to be seen a couple weeks later out havin fun, and hangin out wit other girls. He needs to just go away from the celebrity world, and go get some serious help. Even though he hasnt been in trouble with the cops before, he should of been put to prison, that might smarten him up and realize what he did wrong. And if shes stupid to take him back, well shes just dumb, but when you love someone its hard to let go and u always think maybe he can change, and despite the bad times we had, we also had good times. So shes always going to love him, im guessing her family keeps her grounded and reminds her that shes better than that, and she can do better for herself.

  20. Sarah Jane says:

    @Spice – Thank you for having the most sensible post in this whole thread.

1 2 3

Leave a Reply

It's easier to leave comments when you register for an account, where you can also select your own profile photo. Already have a PITNB account? Then sign in.

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.