Jul 28, 2009
Kelly Clarkson Is Pissed Her Song ‘Already Gone’ Sounds A Lot Like ‘Halo’ By Beyoncé
Blames her song co-writer, who wrote both songs

Kelly Clarkson, who just released the music video for her new single Already Gone, is spitting mad that folks think that she ripped off the music of her newest single from Beyoncé‘s hit single Halo … particularly because she is among the folks who can hear the striking similarity. In a new interview with CBC Radio, Kelly fumes about the fact that co-writer Ryan Tedder (from the band One Republic who penned Already Gone AND Halo) appears to have sold both ladies the same song with different lyrics … and she is pissed!


If you’ve noticed similarities between Kelly Clarkson’s new single “Already Gone” and Beyoncé’s hit “Halo,” well, you’re not the only one. Turns out Clarkson has also noticed, and she’s not too happy about it. In an interview with Canada’s CBC radio network, the former “American Idol” champ said she was unaware of any similarities between her song and Beyoncé’s “Halo” until she heard the two songs side by side (according to Clarkson, her All I Ever Wanted album was finished before Beyoncé’s I Am … Sasha Fierce was released). And she’s not mincing words about who she blames for the similarities: OneRepublic frontman Ryan Tedder, who co-wrote both songs. “Ryan and I met each other at the record label, before he was working with anyone else. He’s from Oklahoma, I’m from Texas; we got along really well and had some of the same influences,” Clarkson said. “We wrote about six songs together, four or five of them made the album. It was all fine and dandy. I’d never heard of a song called ‘Halo’ … [Beyoncé's] album came out when my album was already being printed. “No one’s gonna be sittin’ at home, thinkin’ ‘Man, Ryan Tedder gave Beyoncé and Kelly the same track to write to,’ ” she continued. “No, they’re just gonna be sayin’ I ripped someone off. I called Ryan and said, ‘I don’t understand. Why would you do that?’ ” “Gone” and “Halo” do share some striking similarities, most notably in the backing track, which features somber piano, crashing drums and hand-claps. Clarkson — who clashed with her label in the past — said that she’s upset that “Already Gone” was released as a single without her blessing, but that, at this point, there’s really nothing to do about the situation. “It sucks, but it’s one of those things I have no control over,” she told the CBC. “I already made my album. At this point, the record company can do whatever they want with it. It’s kind of a shitty situation, but … you know, you learn.” At press time, a spokesperson for Tedder had not responded to MTV News’ request for comment on the situation.

To be honest, I didn’t immediately notice the similarity between the songs when I heard them both separately … at different times. But since the release of Kelly‘s new single, I thought it sounded very familiar … and then the handclaps cued me in to the Halo recognition. Shoot, if I were her … I’d be pissed, too … especially since despite the fact that Kelly‘s album was finished first, Halo was released months ago well ahead of the release of Already Gone. Methinks Mr. Ryan Tedder has got some ‘splainin’ to do. After the jump, check out the music videos for both Kelly Clarkson‘s Already Gone and Beyoncé‘s Halo for a side-by-side comparison …



What do YOU think? Are they the same song? Try and play them at the same time … they almost match up perfectly. HMMM … should Kelly and Beyoncé both kick Ryan Tedder‘s ass? I’m thinkin’ … yes.

[Source]

Like PITNB on Facebook

78 Comments. Add Yours

1 2 3 4
  1. Joanne says:

    This makes me realise how incestuous the music industry is … and the lack of originality. What happened to singer songwriters? Kelly’s latest CD sounds so overproduced … It’s getting hard to tell who is singing – they all sound the same.

  2. Joanne says:

    Kelly has it in her to write her own material … screw her record company. Now that she made up with her record company and did this album to please them, she needs to do her own thing. At some point you have to break out of the box.

  3. ari says:

    lmao. I like Beyonce’s better anyway. She is a MUCH better vocalist. And Kelly sucks live.

  4. Chris says:

    These two songs sound so much the same you can switch back and forth seamlessly after each chorus! Of course, different people are going to put different spins on their recordings, but the basic music is the same. The songwriter should be sued, and I don’t blame Kelly for complaining. What a jerk!!!

  5. Ashley H says:

    I dunno, I don’t really hear it, maybe I’m silly! I hear One Republic, who I love, and probably the reason I love both of these so much! I think they have very different feels, one R&B-ish, and one more pop-y.

  6. CG13 says:

    They’re very similar, but Kelly’s version is way better. I’m so excited for her to perform in the VH1 Divas show on September 17th! She’s performing with Adele, Miley Cyrus, and Leona Lewis, all AMAZING SINGERS. If you love Kelly like I do, go to divastories.vh1.com and submit a story about how Kelly inspires you. GO KELLY

  7. cherrr says:

    @ari.. i don’t know where you heard kelly live, but I’ve def heard her & she is amazing. She’s one of the few singers these days who can actually SING, & I think its totally refreshing.

    ps. who cares if they’re the same? Halo makes me want to kill myself with a dull blade, and if Kelly can improve upon THAT in any degree I’ll take it.

  8. WTF? says:

    For a song to “sound the same”, it would have to have very similiar MUSIC. You have to compare the songs note-for-note, not just whether there are handclaps, etc… or a similar arrangement. Since the same writer wrote the songs, it would be expected to have a similar style. Otherwise, one could argue that all of the work Timbaland does producing songs for various artists (regardless of who wrote them) “sound the same” because of what he brings to the production process is similar in vein, and therefore something of a “signature” sound that we equate with him. I mean, regardless of the song and who wrote it, you know a Pet Shop Boys production when you hear one. And conversely, you can spot a Prince, Bee Gee’s, or Carlos Santana song regardless who is singing it. So, unless someone pulls out the sheet music and compares them, it’s stupid to argue the question. Their respective producers may have arranged them similarly, simply based upon popular style, but if the notes are different, then they are different songs. I think it just goes to show how many people are actually very ignorant about the music they listen to.

  9. Talitha says:

    a lot of similarities..in my opinion.

  10. Sam says:

    Kelly is a right bitch for even mentioning anything about this.
    Now in all of this its not Kelly or Beyonce who look the bad guys but Ryan. People get over it, yes they have a bit of similarity but only music wise. In meaning they are two completely different songs so people should respect that. Ryan IMO unlike some is the freshest and actual talented singer/songwriter out there at da moment!
    Phew-thats for Ryan and One Republic!
    P.s. I love Already Gone and Halo and gotta say HATS OFF TO RYAN!

  11. Jay Z says:

    It’s not kell’s fault Ryan tedder is the one that composed both songs !!! and in my oppinion Already gone is WAYYY BETTER THAN HALO !!!!!

  12. Best you could edit the webpage name Kelly Clarkson Is Pissed Her Song ‘Already Gone’ Sounds A Lot Like ‘Halo’ By Beyoncé | Pink is the New Blog | Everybody's Business Is My Business to more generic for your blog post you write. I enjoyed the the writing yet.

1 2 3 4

Leave a Reply

It's easier to leave comments when you register for an account, where you can also select your own profile photo. Already have a PITNB account? Then sign in.

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.