Robert Downey, Jr. Reveals Sherlock’s Man Crush On Watson


Speaking at the panel discussion for his upcoming film Sherlock Holmes at 2009 San Diego Comic-Con this weekend, Robert Downey, Jr. revealed to fans that there may be some overt man-on-man “love” (ie. affection) going on in the film. While he didn’t go so far as to say that Sherlock Holmes and his sidekick Dr. John H. Watson would be lovers, he did reveal that the men are very, very close in the film … as a result of, what he calls, “circumstantial homosexuality”. Shoot, whatever he calls it … I’m all for it!

Will Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson be the latest bromance to hit Hollywood? Robert Downey Jr., who plays Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s classic fictional character opposite Jude Law’s Watson in Guy Ritchie’s remake of Sherlock Holmes thinks he and Law have some sexy chemistry together. “It’s called circumstantial homosexuality,” he jokingly told the press at Comic-Con Friday, after leading lady Rachel McAdams suggested the film’s central love story is really between the sleuth and his sidekick. The two actors took to each other even before Law signed on to the part. Downey was sent to meet his future costar and “sell” him on the role and “Jude walks down the hall and my assistant – who never cares about anything – is standing in the hall and she’s like, ‘Oh my God, there he is!’ He was dressed in that kind of fabulous, super expensive, under-dressed way. “I said, ‘Dude’ – and literally before he said he was going to do the movie, before he said that he was available, before he said that he either did or didn’t want to be courted, we just started talking like two serious actors about what would need to happen to make this work as a piece of straight drama. We just became really close really quickly, because we just rolled up our sleeves and started working from jump.” Downey said Law, who is currently performing Hamlet on stage in London, “is so the right arm of this movie.” But good thing for the ladies, the film isn’t just about male bonding. Downey shares some romantic moments with McAdams – but “not enough for my taste,” he said.

Oh man … how awesome is this. You gotta love actors that are secure enough in their manhood that they can willingly and believingly play male characters that show love and affection for one another without it necessarily being a gay lovestory. While I would have no problem with Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson being lovers, that development doesn’t really jibe with the lore that we all know and love. That said, the men are very close and I’m happy to know that that closeness will be respected in the film version of the book series. I have full confidence that RDJ and Jude will do great justice to the beloved characters that they portray … and if they want to take the relationship to a bromantic level, who are we to argue?


  • CB

    Isn’t “circumstantial homosexuality” what happens in prison? (I keed, I keed!)

  • Juneh

    Hahaha, those captions are too funny ;D
    I love me some Jude Law and Robert Downey Jr. together <3.

  • Mr. Gyllenhaal

    Hey, I want to see the X-ratedness anytime!

  • LOVE G

    ROBERT DOWNEY JR HAS ALWAYS BEEN AWESOME.. i’m really glad he has his shit together again :D i love his work!

  • Jenn

    if rachel gets in jude’s way of robert then he can punch her in the head like that photographer. wait, what?

  • I love me some RDJ. He is soooo funny and hot.

  • wishinchick

    The picture and captions are almost too perfect haha

  • MoroccoMole

    This isn’t anything new — Billy Wilder’s “The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes” in the 1970s hinted at a homoerotic connection between the great sleuth and his sidekick Dr. Watson.

  • Jazz

    Woohoo!! RDJ!!