Bummer news for fans of the Twilight movie (possibly) … Catherine Hardwicke, the woman who directed the film (which made $70+ million at the box office on opening weekend) and was on track to direct the movie’s sequel New Moon (and possibly the rest of the franchise), has been fired by the movie studio! Clearly this was a big shock to Hardwicke who, just a few days ago, was giving interviews where she was already talking about her plans for directing the next movie (ie. she was planning to begin filming New Moon around March of ’09 with a 2010 release for the film). I understand that Hardwicke is currently still on the road promoting Twilight as news of her firing is making the rounds. No word yet on who has been chosen to replace her but one thing’s for sure … Catherine Hardwicke will not be making any more films for the Twilight saga:

So the rumors are true. I’ve confirmed that Summit Entertainment is taking Twilight director Catherine Hardwicke off the sequel in this big new franchise. No doubt my news will speed up the studio’s announcement, and Summit will surely scramble to spin this as all going down amicably along the lines that she “couldn’t fit the film into her time frame”. But this terrible news for Hardwicke comes just as she and the Twilight cast are on their European press tour. No doubt, tomorrow’s interviews in France will now focus entirely on what, if anything, Catherine did to deserve this treatment. This also could blow up into a scandal for Summit if it chooses a male director over Hardwicke, whose Twilight easily beat Mimi Leder’s 1998 Deep Impact box office gross as the biggest opener for a female director. That was a record embraced by Hollywood feminists as a sign of growing gal power. Now Hardwicke’s career will surely be damaged by this very public firing because, even though the pic was skewered by critics, it is already a $160M low-cost blockbuster. Summit has started preparing the sequel New Moon, based on Meyer’s second book in the series, and, to contain costs, the studio is considering making third book Eclipse back to back). The word from inside Summit is that Hardwicke, the acclaimed Thirteen director, “was ‘difficult’ and ‘irrational’ during the making of Twilight,” one insider explains to me. “That doesn’t mean anything when you’re talking about a filmmaker because they all are, but still…” (Indeed, Joe Roth and Sony kept saying those things about Julie Taymor on Across The Universe. Yet she made a cult classic and is now directing Marvel/Sony’s Spider-Man for Broadway.) From another of my sources, “Summit didn’t like her. They’re saying the DP [director of photography] Elliot Davis is the one responsible for the film’s sumptuous visual look, that the editor Nancy Richardson had to save the film in post-production, and Summit thought Hardwicke’s [CAA] agent Beth Swofford was alternately ineffectual and hysterical [when it came to controlling her client].” In fact, I’m told that the studio has even had quiet talks with other CAA directors for the last week. “And Swofford never told Hardwicke about that and that she was about to get kicked to the gutter,” an insider tells me. “To add insult to injury, Hardwicke can now look forward to being grilled by the press for days on end, in front of the cast, about why she’s getting shit-canned.”
Damn, that really does suck. Here is a report from MTV just a few days ago where Hardwicke was talking about her plans to begin filming the next movie:
“Well, right now we’re trying to figure out if the studio people, and me, and everyone’s on the same page,” the “Twilight” director explained exclusively to MTV News, addressing the fans who’ve already begun debating where — and with whom — the franchise should go from here. “I want to do ['New Moon'] better than we did ‘Twilight,’ and do it really cool. I definitely don’t want to do it as something just tossed off, like a ‘Saw II’ or something like that. We want to be sure that it’s really going to be great and that everyone’s on the same page. “I would say that the film could be finished by the end of 2009, if not the beginning of 2010; cameras could be rolling in about five months,” Hardwicke said of her March/April timetable, should she return to helm the pic. “We spent about a year and three months getting ['Twilight'] ready, between writing the script and casting. We could probably do things a little bit faster this time, but who knows? It depends. And sometimes you can do things really fast. You can get two editors on, and you can just zip through.”
The report goes on HERE and talks about her vision for the way she was planning to handle the logistics of bringing Jacob‘s character to live in New Moon (read on if you dare but beware of spoilers) but it looks like, at this point, all of her comments are moot. Personally, I think Hardwicke did a great job adapting the book into movie. I agree that it would look very suspicious if the movie studio decides to hand the director’s chair over to a male director. It seems to me that the woman responsible for setting the new box office record for the biggest opening weekend gross by a female director should be allowed to direct the next movie in the franchise. I suspect fans that weren’t happy with the way the movie was adapted might be pleased by this news. I dunno … it seems very wrong to me. What do y’all think? Should Catherine Hardwicke be replaced?
[Photo credit: Bauer-Griffin; Source, Source]





























definitely! she ruined the story with her horrible directing. There were so many scenes I was looking forward to, only to be disappointed. Who cares if the next director is male or female, as long as he/she is skilled and does the book justice.
Also wanted to add that they should recast Rosalie. She was only hired b/c she was Catherine’s stepdaughter. The role should have been cast because of talent, not who you know. She did a horrible job of Rosalie and was not even a tenth as beautiful as she should have been.
I am a huge fan of the Twilight Book Series but I was utterly disappointed in this movie. If you didn’t read the book I don’t think you would be able to follow this movie…or even feel the intense story line that those who read the book felt. I think there was bad acting, bad screen play, bad special effects and bad directing. I have seen many of these actors in other movies where they did a great job so I don’t think it was that they couldn’t act…I just thing they didn’t have a good script to work with and the director didn’t do a good job. So I am not sorry to see Catherine let go. BUT with that said…I hope that Summit Entertainment stops being cheap and throws more money at this next movie. They made a lot of money on this frist movie because of anticipation…but if they made a second sucky movie they are not going to make as much the second time around. Fans are being forgiving for this first one, but I don’t think they will be as forgiving a second time around. And I don’t care if it is a female director or a male director…as long as whoever directs this film does a good job.
oh, i agree with lizindc : )
the movie didnt put out any of the fuzzy warm feelings i got from the book. the script made me flinch becuase it was so uncomfortable and there was no feeling : (. i wanted the movie to make me swoonnn ♥
the movie was horrible! a new director is a postive thing … now if they woud get a new screenwriter the sequels can actually be good
I know the number one problem with Twilight was a lack of money and the reports I have read is that Summit wants to make New Moon for the same amount of money the spent on Twilight a whole 30 mil. This is a terrible terrible thing. I was a bit perplexed throughout the film and was left wanting more. I think that a new director will be fine if not possibly a vast improvement. The one thing they can not change is Robert Pattinson he of course made the movie for me. Even more then his beautiful face was his great portrayal of Edward. I thought he did a wonderful job with what he had to work with. Crossing my fingers for Alfonso Cuaron :)
This is excellent news, yes the film was low budget but that’s not the main reason it was lacking. The directing was horrendous…did anyone else realize that the never explained why edward was missing from school? or why there was no explanation as to why his eyes change colour?…the only people that would understand this is the upset people who read the book. This kind of stuff the director should think about when making a film, she forgot to add some major points in the film that make sense. I agree with some of the others on here too, the editing was really choppy, it felt like you were watching a montage of clips rather than a highly anticipated film. Overall, this is a great move by Summit!
I’m glad she’s gone but I’m worried canning her won’t solve all the problems the movie had…fingers crossed New Moon kicks ass. I’ll see it either way though – the studio executives know that and that could be the sequal’s downfall.
i know little about the movie making magic and who does what but i know that catherine’s previous films have been indys and low budget (good movies don’t get me wrong i am a huge fan of thirteen) with not alot of special effects and new moon is going to have to show jacob and jared phasing in to werewolves and show all 5 werewolves going after laurent…. sooooo, i think they may want a director with experience in movies with lots more special effects. twilight had some and i thought they were good… i am the minority on that.
i am not that upset about her getting replaced… look what the new directors did for the hp franchise.
To all those little kiddies out there crying in their sorrow and making really pathetic little online petition’s. Get a life. If you had a real idea you would see that this was the best move. So what if Nikki and Kristen are going to be big bitches on set because their weirdo director got the axe, they seriously need to get over themselves. And really who gives a F— if the director is MALE or FEMALE!!!
I think there was so much foundation and potential for the movie to be great, and I was very disappointed. I think this is a great move.
Did you guys seriously think the movie was going to be exactly like the book?!?! The book was amazing and yes they did change a lot, but you cannot get all of that into an already two hour long movie! Sasha does make some very good points, and I agree that it could’ve been better. I am a Twilight fanatic and I still loved the movie…that’s just my opinion :)
I think this will be for the best, the movie did nothing for me…. except drool over edward cullen. I agree that the movie only made so much money because of the story of twilight… not because of who the director is.
I love the books! They were amazing and different, more so than almost anything else out there right now. The movie should have been the same but because of poor directing it wasn’t as amazing as it could have been. I could even live with the effects and script the way they were, but come on that sence when Edward first smells Bella! Crap!!!I just hope that the person (man or woman) that will be doing the next film can keep their own ideas to a minimum and simple make the movie something that resembles the story of New Moon. I’ve given up on ever seeing a movie that does a book justice but I believe they can make an amazing movie with the right person behind the camera.
Wow, I agree with so much on here. I enjoyed all 4 books (although the first part of the 4th was a little bit weird for me) but overall it was a good reading experience and I was really excited for the movie. But after seeing it, I was extremely disappointed. Even my husband (who also liked the series) said that it was the worst book adaptation to film ever (I disagree, I think Timeline by Micheal Crichton was the worst….closely tied with Eragon, unfortunately.) At any rate, almost everything in the film felt awkward, the landscape was lovely but the acting was not great. So much stuff went unexplained and I think that if I hadn’t read the books I would be so confused and unsatisfied because my brain wouldn’t have been able to fill in the missing parts with info from the book. Of course it’s not going to be exact, but we know from other movies that have been adapted from books that if you really take the time and make the effort to make it good it will be. And it wasn’t. So I hope they do a better job next time!!! Also, I agree…man, woman, doesn’t matter, just do a good job directing!
wow i didn’t suspect so many people would have complained about how the movie was, but like the rest of you … i thought it severely lacking. it felt too forced to be the book (if that makes any sense).
but shoot, harry potter has different directors and it’s number one opening night.
You know who they should really get rid of?
The screenwriter. She needs to go.
I didnt know WHY i hated this movie until i realized this woman directed it. Ive seen almost all of her major movies and despise them ALL!!!
GOOD BYE LADY!
maybe the next one wont feel like im watching a horror original that would’ve premiered on “The N”
this is great. they should really just….not make the movies. period.
the movie was a horrible misrepresentation of the book….i dont understand how anyone who hadnt read it could understand what the hell was going on.
these past few months, i feel like ive been watching edward cullen get raped repeatedly.
no need to ruin such an amazing story three more times…
but im sure they will.
I’m completely on the fence when it comes to this announcement. On the one hand I think she did a fairly decent job with what she had to work with. I definitely think the special effects needed a lot of work, I think that there should have been more dialogue from the text (i.e. “do I dazzle you”) and I was highly disappointed with the big “fight” scene. I will say I did like her casting decisions. The Cullen family was basically how I pictured them in my head and my favorite parts of the movie were the scenes with Kristen and Rob because their chemistry just burst out of the freaking screen (I’ve seen the movie more than once and I still think that). That being said I think the best scenes in the movie were the scenes with just Kristen and Rob. I definitely don’t like the beginning I think it’s too choppy and just not done well. Hopefully whomever they hire to replace her will keep the charm of the books and make New Moon flow a little better… ohh and figure out how to not make us watch Jacob fawn over a broken-hearted Bella for more than half the movie… I think most people would agree that 300 pages was enough the first time around!